Mark Veltzer's personal site

The Soul That Wasn't There

4 min read religion bible history atheism

Ask most people what Judaism and Christianity teach about death and they'll tell you the same thing: you have a soul, and it lives on after your body dies. It sounds ancient and fundamental. But open the Torah and look for it. You won't find it.

What Genesis actually says

In Genesis 2:7, God forms the man from the dust of the ground and breathes into his nostrils nishmat chayim, the breath of life, and the man becomes a nefesh chayah, a living creature. That's it. Breath. A living, breathing animal made of dirt. And notice what that means for death: when you die, you stop breathing. The breath God breathed into you is simply gone. It doesn't go anywhere. It doesn't travel to heaven or wait in some chamber; it just stops. So the breath of Genesis is not the equivalent of a soul. Life is breath, and death is its absence. The same phrase, nefesh chayah, is used for the animals a few verses earlier. Nothing in the text says God installed an immortal, detachable essence that would outlive the body.

When people in the early books of the Hebrew Bible die, they go down to Sheol, a dim, shadowy pit where everyone ends up, righteous and wicked alike. No reward, no punishment, no heaven. Ecclesiastes puts it bluntly: the same fate comes to humans and animals, and all go to one place. The God of the Torah makes his promises about this life: land, descendants, rain in its season, long days. Not paradise.

Where the soul came from

The immortal soul shows up late, very late by the standards of a tradition that traces itself back to Abraham. Around 165 BCE, the Book of Daniel speaks of the dead waking, some to everlasting life. That's resurrection of the body, not a soul. Only around then and after, in Jewish writings shaped by the Greek world, such as 1 Enoch, the Wisdom of Solomon and Philo of Alexandria, do we find souls waiting in chambers or resting "in the hand of God." By the first century, Josephus reports that the Pharisees believed souls are immortal.

The source is not hard to spot. The immortal soul is Plato's idea. Hellenistic Judaism absorbed it from the surrounding Greek culture, and early Christianity, born out of that same world, inherited it too. Later rabbinic tradition built it into an elaborate system of nefesh, ruach and neshama. A borrowed idea became a pillar of faith. (I traced this history in more detail in The Evolution of the Immortal Soul.)

Why it caught on

The usual scholarly explanation is sympathetic. During the persecution under Antiochus IV, faithful Jews were tortured and killed for keeping the law. The old promise of a good life for the righteous had obviously failed. So the reward was moved somewhere it could never be checked: after death.

Call it what it is. When a promise fails, and instead of admitting it you move the payout to a place no one comes back from, you aren't dealing with reality. You're bullshitting. And the most effective bullshitters are the ones who have bullshitted themselves first. The preachers who spread the immortal soul probably believed it, which is exactly what made it so persuasive to everyone else. An idea that rescues your theology, comforts your followers and can never be disproven is almost too useful not to adopt. (More on why that kind of belief deserves the name in Sacred Bullshit.)

And it worked. Both Judaism and Christianity grew around a promise that their own oldest scriptures never make.

The case on the other side

To be fair, defenders of the tradition would push back in a few ways:

  • Religions develop. Traditions grow by interpreting their texts, and the rabbis and Church Fathers saw the soul as unfolding what was already implied, not as an invention.
  • Hints in the text. Some point to Ecclesiastes 12:7, "the spirit returns to God who gave it," or to Saul summoning Samuel at Endor, as signs of survival after death in the older books.
  • Sincerity isn't fraud. Historians stress that the people who formed these beliefs were wrestling honestly with suffering and justice. By Harry Frankfurt's definition, bullshitting means indifference to truth, and these thinkers cared about it intensely.
  • Origin isn't refutation. Showing where an idea came from doesn't show it's false. Whether anything survives death is a separate question (one I take up in What Brain Damage Tells Us About the Soul).

The historical facts aren't really in dispute: the immortal soul is absent from the Torah and arrived later, under Greek influence. What you make of that is up to you.