Steering or Drifting: The Accounting
Contents
A few years ago I asked whether humanity is steering or drifting: on the line from full conscious control of our future to none, where are we? I sketched three domains, the economy, government and the direction of history, and guessed at a pattern: we have traded the ability to steer for safety from bad steering, one sensible decision at a time, and nobody ever added up the total.
I also admitted that the real work was the accounting I hadn't done. Here it is, for six more domains. The question for each is the same: does this increase or decrease our collective ability to decide something and then do it?
Law
Law looks like the steering wheel itself. It's how a society tells itself what to do. In practice it behaves more like sediment. Statutes pile up and are rarely repealed. Courts are bound by earlier courts. Constitutions are made hard to change on purpose, and judges can strike down what a majority just decided. Every one of those features protects somebody from an abuse that really happened.
The result is that each generation inherits more rules it didn't write and can't easily remove. Law is a ratchet: easy to add, hard to take away.
Verdict: less steering. The past holds more and more of the wheel.
Science funding
Nobody decides what humanity should find out next. Money goes to thousands of separate projects, picked by committees of scientists judging each other's proposals. That's deliberate, and mostly right, since nobody knows where the next discovery is.
The exceptions are worth looking at. The Manhattan Project, Apollo, and the rush for a COVID vaccine show that science can be aimed, fast, when a government declares an emergency and pays for it. We know how to steer here. We do it only when frightened.
Verdict: drift by default, steering by exception.
Media
To decide anything together, a society first has to look at the same thing at the same time. For a few decades it could. A handful of newspapers and broadcasters set a shared agenda. They did it badly and with plenty of bias, but it was shared.
That's gone. Attention is now handed out by feeds built to keep each person scrolling, and what each person sees is different. No editor chooses the agenda, and the algorithm has no opinion about what matters. It was built to hold attention, and that's all it does.
Verdict: much less steering, and the sharpest drop of the six.
Education
Education is the odd one. Here the state really does steer: school is compulsory, and someone writes the curriculum. If there's one place where we decide what the next generation will be like, it's this.
And yet the classroom, the timetable, the subjects and the exams are recognisably those of the nineteenth century. Curricula change by adding, not by rethinking. Everyone with a stake can block a change and no one can force one.
Verdict: there is a wheel, and nobody is turning it.
Corporate structure
A corporation is the best steering machine we've built. It sets a goal, assigns people, measures results and corrects course. Inside the firm there is nothing feather-like at all.
But look at who chooses the goal. Ownership is spread across millions of shareholders, most of whom hold the company through a fund and don't know they own it. Managers answer for one number. So the most capable organisations on earth are pointed, by design, at a target that no person picked, and they aren't free to aim at anything else.
Verdict: superb steering in the small, drift in the large.
International institutions
Our biggest problems are the size of the planet. Our decisions are the size of a country. Between countries there are treaties that bind only those who sign, a Security Council where five members can each veto anything, and no enforcement to speak of.
Again the exceptions teach the most. Smallpox was wiped out by a coordinated world campaign. The Montreal Protocol got the chemicals that destroy the ozone layer phased out. Both problems were narrow, measurable, and technically solvable, with few losers.
Verdict: almost no steering, with two instructive successes.
The total
Add these to the first three and the pattern holds, with one refinement I didn't see before.
It isn't that we can't steer. We steer very well in three situations: inside a single organisation with a single goal, in a declared emergency, and on a narrow technical problem where the fix is clear and few people lose. What we can't do is steer on problems that are slow, spread out, and tangled up with values. Those happen to be the ones that matter most.
So the trade I guessed at is real, and it has a shape. We kept the ability to steer in the small and gave it up in the large. The parts row hard, each in its own direction, and the whole thing floats.
I wouldn't undo the trades. Separation of powers, independent courts and free markets were answers to real horrors. What's missing is smaller: anyone whose job is the total. No institution asks, of each new safeguard, how much ability to act we have left. A modest start would be laws that expire unless renewed, and an agreed, deliberate way to declare a slow problem an emergency before it becomes a fast one.
The other side
The strongest objection is that drift is the point. Friedrich Hayek argued that no central mind can hold the knowledge that is spread through a whole society, so systems nobody steers will outperform systems somebody does. The twentieth century offers support: the societies that steered hardest, the Soviet Union and Mao's China, steered into famine. Meanwhile the drifting world has become richer, healthier and longer-lived than any planned one. It may be that what looks like floating is a very large number of small corrections, and that this is the only kind of steering a complex civilisation can survive. My answer is that this defends drifting on problems that can be solved piece by piece, and says nothing about the ones that can't.